- Iris Kiss Kiss 5
- Irwin 1
- Isabel Dark 2
- Isabel Dean 1
- Isabel Torvos 1
- Isabell Moon 1
- Isabella Chrystin 2
- Isabella Clark 13
- Isabella Della 2
- Isabella Lui 1
- Isabella Nice 1
- Isabella Sky 1
- Isadora 2
- Isiah Maxwell 8
- Isis Love 1
- Isis Taylor 1
- Isla 1
- Ivana Jones 1
- Ivi Rein 6
- Ivy Lebelle 2
- Ivy Wolfe 1
- IvyRae 1
- Izabela Pimenta 1
- Izzy Bell 1
- J Mac 8
- Jack Hammer 1
- Jack Lawrence 2
- Jack Rippher 4
- Jack Vegas 1
- Jacqueline Summers 1
- Jacqui Banks 1
- Jada Fire 1
- Jada Stevens 4
- Jade Aspen 1
- Jade Nile 2
- Jade Rox 1
- JadeKink 1
- Jaelyn Fox 1
- Jaime Fetti 2
- Jakar 5
- Jake Adams 2
- James Angel 2
- James Dane 1
- James Deen 12
- Jamie Barry 2
- Jamie Brooks 1
- Jamie Foster 1
- Jamie Rae 1
- Jamie Ray 1
- Jane Darling 1
- Jane Marie 1
- Jane Way 1
- Jani Bell 1
- Janice Griffith 2
- Jasmine Black 1
- Jasmine Caro 1
- Jasmine Dark 3
- Jasmine Daze 5
- Jasmine Grey 1
- Jasmine Jae 8